Loading…
30
Hot take: cash in envelopes beat my $12 a month budgeting app, and it wasn't close
I used a budgeting app for 8 months and still felt broke every Friday, so I switched to the envelope method last January with $340 in cash for groceries and gas. The app showed me pretty pie charts after the money was already gone, but handing over real bills made me stop and think before every single purchase. In month one I had $60 left in the grocery envelope, which never happened once in 8 months of tapping my phone at the register. Some folks say cash is outdated and apps are the smarter way, but my bank balance says otherwise, your mileage may vary. I still track bills in a spreadsheet, I just don't trust an app to do the part that needs willpower. Has anyone else tried both and had the apps actually win, or did cash change things for you too?
1 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In1 Comment
jana88121d ago
The part about apps showing you pie charts after the money is gone is the thing nobody talks about. Friction. An app makes spending smooth, one tap and done, and that smoothness works against you when the goal is to slow down. I read somewhere that people spend more with cards than cash, like 12 to 18 percent more, just because handing over bills actually registers as a loss in your brain. Your $60 leftover in month one is that loss feeling doing its job. Spreadsheet plus cash is basically you being the software, which sounds dumb until you realize the software was never the hard part.
0