Used to spike every codominant union on red oaks, now I subordinate cut and the woundwood tells the story
For my first 6 years climbing I was taught to drill a spike hole and bolt every tight codominant union on red oaks, figured more steel meant more safe. After a job in Madison last spring where a 22 inch oak with 4 bolts failed anyway at the union, I switched to reduction cuts on the competing leader and letting the tree build its own wood. Two seasons in, the callus wood is closing over clean and I am not punching holes in live tissue for no reason. Anyone else make this switch, and do you still bolt anything under 30 inches DBH?
Bolting has its place but punching holes in every tight union was never the answer. Subordination cuts let the tree do the work, steel is backup not a fix.