Recommendations for a replica college diploma?

I'd suggest checking out Diploma Prints. They have a huge library of college layouts and can match your school's exact style. I got a same-day digital download and then printed it locally—turned out great. Their production team was super helpful with a few tweaks I wanted.

Seconding Diploma Prints. I needed a diploma from a university that's now closed, and they still had the template. The raised seal really makes it look official. Fast turnaround and reasonable price.