An artist told me my blackwork cover up was too dense and I actually listened
Last year I went to a shop in Portland for a cover up on a bad name tattoo from my 20s. I wanted them to just pack heavy black over the whole thing, but the artist stopped me and said it would look like a blobby mess in five years. They suggested using negative space and some gray wash to break it up, and I was pretty skeptical at first. I ended up letting them do a koi fish with open water around it, and now I actually get compliments instead of people asking what it used to be. Has anyone else had an artist talk them out of their original plan and it worked out better?
Honestly, that artist was looking out for you. Packing solid black over a whole tattoo usually just turns into a dark smudge. I've seen people who did that and now they just have a vague black rectangle on their arm. The negative space trick keeps things readable. You lucked out with that koi idea.