Loading…

My buddy's nebula photo made me question our editing ethics | Astronomy Photos - Free To Speak

My buddy's nebula photo made me question our editing ethics

Last month, a friend shared a shot of the Orion Nebula in our group chat, and the colors were way too bright. I know his telescope and camera, so I asked how he got such vivid hues. He confessed he stacked over fifty images and pushed the saturation sliders to the max. He never mentioned this when posting, making it seem like a single exposure. This bugs me because beginners see this and think they need top gear to capture color, when it's mostly editing. I called him out, saying we should be clear about our process, but he argued that all astro photos are edited anyway. Now there's a weird vibe in the group. If we don't admit how much we tweak our shots, we're just fooling ourselves and others.

4 comments

4 Comments

quinn_burns6mo ago

Doesn't over-editing hide the real learning curve?

kaigibson6mo ago

It's more like editing for polish instead of progress hides it... focusing on making stuff look good rather than showing how it really works.

the_christopher5mo ago

Yeah, that's a good question. In my experience, you have to learn what the camera actually captured first before you go crazy with sliders. I started by trying to make every shot look like what @park.miles described, super colorful and wild, but my early edits were a mess because I didn't understand the raw data. Once I spent time learning what a decent but basic edit looked like, all that fancy stuff made more sense and I could actually control it. Jumping straight to the final look just taught me how to copy steps, not why things were changing.

park.miles6mo ago

Look, the whole point of astro photography is to show what the eye can't see. Cameras grab light over time, and editing just brings out the hidden colors and details. For example, that Orion Nebula shot probably looked flat and dull straight out of the camera. Pushing saturation makes it look like the Hubble images, which are all edited too. Tbh, if your friend didn't say how he did it, so what? Everyone knows these pics are worked on. Beginners will figure out that editing is a big part of it when they start. Honestly, getting upset about it just makes the hobby less fun for everyone.