Loading…
4
The change I noticed in book club discussions after 2020
I remember back in 2018 our little group in Portland would sit around and argue about plot holes for hours. We had this one debate over 'The Nickel Boys' that went late into the night. But after 2020, something shifted. Suddenly every discussion turned into a therapy session about trauma or what the author's personal life was like. I get it, times were rough, but now it feels like nobody wants to just say a book was good or bad without turning it into a moral test. Last month we read 'Project Hail Mary' and two people almost walked out because someone joked the science was goofy. Has anyone else seen their group lose that casual arguing spirit?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
smith.parker1mo ago
Has anyone else's book club become allergic to fun takes? I swear the whole vibe changed from debating plot mechanics to analyzing every single character's trauma like it's a diagnostic manual. The Project Hail Mary thing is wild, that book is literally about a guy saving the world with science jokes. You can't even laugh at the absurdity without someone getting offended over the science not being totally accurate. I miss when we could just say a book was dumb fun without turning it into a moral referendum.
2
logan5611mo ago
Man, you nailed it. Books like Project Hail Mary are pure entertainment, not some textbook to nitpick for errors. I feel like people forget you can just enjoy a wild ride without putting every detail under a microscope. What happened to just letting the fun parts be fun?
3
smith.parker1mo ago
...wait, hold on, someone actually got offended over the science in Project Hail Mary? That is genuinely shocking to me. I mean, the whole thing is built around absurd concepts like a spider alien and a guy solving problems with duct tape and grit. It's basically a love letter to the idea that science can be fun and messy, not a lecture you'd find in a textbook. If you're reading that book and getting hung up on the accuracy of astrophysical calculations, you've completely missed the point of the ride. Sometimes a story is just meant to make you smile and feel clever, not pass a peer review.
1